The MMR vaccine and autism – what’s all that about? Part I

In my previous post about measles imported to Israel from the UK, I intimated we had a British doctor named Andrew Wakefield to thank for our current predicament. This is your cue to ask, in your best Emily Litella voice, “What’s all this I hear about Andrew Wakeup?”…well, you’ve come to the right place.

Andrew Wakefield is a British-born, Canadian-trained gastroenterological surgeon who in 1998, published a study, which described a supposedly new gastrointestinal syndrome in twelve children with developmental disorders, eight of whom allegedly developed their neurological symptoms after their routine MMR shots. While the study merely implied a connection between the MMR vaccine and the later development of autism, Wakefield (who was the lead researcher) stated in a video press conference that he would be wary of the combined MMR vaccine and that it should be suspended in favor of giving children 3 separate ones. Unfortunately, this statement, along with the ever-sensationalistic media headlines, provoked a major health scare about the safety of the MMR vaccine. The frightened public’s response was not to demand that babies receive 3 separate vaccines, but to shun the vaccine altogether. Not surprisingly, MMR vaccine uptake fell to a record low of 82% by 2003 from a previous 92%, triggering outbreaks of measles, the most recent one in July-August 2007 in East London.

Meanwhile, an investigative reporter from the Sunday Times, Brian Deer, found that most the 8 children who participated in the 1998 study and whose onset of neurological symptoms were attributed to the MMR vaccine were not ‘randomly selected’ for Wakefield’s study as claimed, but were clients of a legal aid board representing parents of autistic children, who had commissioned Wakefield the year before to find a link between the vaccine and the children’s condition. In addition to 55,000 pounds paid to the hospital he worked in (the Royal Free Hospital), Wakefield had personally been paid huge sums of money to make this association, but neglected to disclose to the editors of the Lancet what amounted to a huge conflict of interest.

Following this disclosure and after seeing the public health consequences of their statements, 10 of the 12 coauthors of the original 1998 study retracted their original interpretation of the study’s results. The editor of the Lancet, Richard Horton, also stated that publication of the study would not have taken place the way it did, had this connection been known prior to publication. The British General Medical Council is also investigating Wakefield and two of his co-authors on the Lancet paper for professional misconduct. Among other charges, Wakefield is accused of paying children attending his son’s birthday party in 1999 for blood samples.

Wakefield left employment at the Royal Free Hospital in 2001, and currently is the director of Thoughtful House, a treatment center for autistic children in Austin, Texas. He continues to push the view that vaccines cause autism, and claims he was a victim of a witch hunt – as claim his many groupies (mostly parents of autistic children who’ve been convinced that their children are “vaccine damaged”).

In the next installment, we’ll be looking at whether there is any scientific merit to the claim the the MMR vaccine causes autism, including a whole lot of resources with which to combat the lies spread by the anti-vaccine crowd on this subject.

add to del.icio.us : Add to Blinkslist : add to furl : Digg it : add to ma.gnolia : Stumble It! : add to simpy : seed the vine : : : TailRank : post to facebook

Advertisements

2 Responses

  1. One key finding of Andrew was that most of the autism cases had severe problems in their ability to process food causing complications with excrement of food after eating it.
    To prove this was factual it was necessary to film the pipes in the digestive track my micro photographic techniques standard in high quality medical diagnosis.
    Why is this normal diagnostic technique not used and even banned for autism cases?
    The refusal of treatment for a blocked digestive system in itself endangers the lives and positive treatment for this condition.
    It is in fact a condition known to occur if the normal anaphylactic response to over vaccination occurs.
    Andrew is being attacked for what was known to vaccine scientists more than 100 years ago.
    It would appear journalists like Brian Deer are arguing that all the science learned from hard work and repetitive confirmation be abandoned to destroy a scientist in preference to an industry that uses techniques known to have risks which they prefer the general public to be in ignorance of?
    John Fryer MSc BSc Chemist

  2. It would be nice if you managed to dredge up some proof to go with what you said. What you wrote sounds like your run-of-the-mill conspiracy theory.

    Some autistic children (not most, and having nothing to do with their vaccination status) have bowel problems, and those who do undergo colonoscopy if it’s deemed medically necessary. It’s a procedure done under general anesthesia in these children, though, so there are ethical considerations regarding colonoscopies done for medical research only.

    Vaccination does not cause the bowel symptoms you claim (with the possible exception of the old rota-virus vaccine, which caused almost immediate symptoms and was swiftly pulled from the market over this), certainly not years after the fact; nor do the autistic children with bowel problems suffering from a “blocked digestive system”, or they’d have to have their bowels surgically resected or disimpacted. And I submit you have no idea what an anaphylactic reaction looks like, nor what “overvaccination” is (but I’m sure it looked pretty on whatever conspiracy theory website you picked it up from).

    I suggest you look at the links I produced to find out the true story, including Brian Deer’s website, which is extensively documented. Andrew Wakefield is a power-hungry cheat who can’t admit his little scheme’s been found out, and he doesn’t deserve the respect you seem to accord him.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: